December 26, 2000
10:38am
My female companion of choice, who lives in Wisconsin and goes to school
in Massachusetts and therefore doesn't get to see me as much as she would
like (and vice versa), is coming down from WI to visit me today and stay
around until the 3rd. Homemade soup and a rented movie are in the works
for tonight, as well as our Christmas gift exchange. So, most of my day
will be spent cleaning and preparing, in order to make her stay as
relaxing and enjoyable as possible.
What music, then, to set the mood for a romantic evening?
Well, I figure I'll start off with my new Getz/Gilberto, in all its
"Girl from Ipanema" glory, since I know the ladies can't get enough of
Stan once they've been properly introduced. Then we'll proceed on to
Blood on the Tracks for dinner. It's possible to make polite dinner
conversation over Dylan, but during those chewing-filled silences, Bob's
got words you can dig in the company of an intelligent person, yo.
What else? If Bob runs out before it's time to start the movie, I think a
little Al Green is in order. It's a cliche, I know, I know, I know, but it
works, mysteriously. Sometimes, you've gotta' go with what you know. So,
anyway, I think I really need to pick up the Rev. Al Green's Greatest
Hits today, among my many errands.
I'm sure more music will be needed later on, and I'll probably go back to
jazz. Yeah, I know you're thinking "Josh talks about listening to jazz all
the time, but he's still hopelessly single", but you, dear reader, must
understand that even jazz is not entirely infallible when it comes to
ROHmance, although Josh really is just a special case, IMHO. So, more
jazz: I'm thinking John Coltrane's Meditations, since it's a short
enough album (not a skronk monster like Interstellar Space), and it
follows a very clear progression as an album: chaos, calm, beauty. You
can't go wrong with Kind of Blue, either, but I think I'd rather
throw in Miles Smiles tonight -- Miles Smiles has a smokier
atmosphere to it when compared to KOB, chiefly because of the
absence of 'Trane and, especially, the ever-cheery Cannonball Adderly, and
the presence of Tony Williams' angular drumming. In KOB, almost
everyone has a strong personality, which makes for pretty diverse soloing;
in Miles Smiles, I get the sense that Miles is the central focus of
the group and his talented proteges help reinforce his personality instead
of asserting their own. That's all to a degree, of course.
At any rate, I'll probably be leaving "Bolero" on the shelf.
1:26am
Also, before I forget: all of us here at jon blog would like to wish josh
blog a well-deserved happy birthday! Yes, that's right, josh blog is
officially one year old today.
Festivities will commence tomorrow evening, central standard time.
Goodnight, folks.
1:12am
Jon's Christmas Loot:
- Charles Mingus, Mingus Ah Um
- Stan Getz and Joao Gilberto, Getz/Gilberto
- Ludwig Wittgenstein, Tractacus Logico-Philosophicus
- Richard P. Feynman, Feynman Lectures on Computation
- $20 gift certificate at Best Buy
- $20 gift certificate at Barnes & Noble (EVIL)
- $40 gift certificate at Prairie
Lights
- and, a nice fly-fishing rod (and case), St. Croix, Pro Graphite, 7'6", 4
wt. Just the thing for all those little NE Iowa trout streams near my
grandma's house.
So. I'll be blowing my Best Buy g.c. on a couple of CDs tomorrow and will
get you my thoughts on my latest acquirings sometime tomorrow night. Also,
last week I was sent Dylan's Blood on the Tracks from a
well-wisher. Good stuff.
I think I will spend my Prairie Lights money on Of
Mind and Music, by Laird Addis, who is a philosophy prof at Iowa
and, in the interest of full disclosure, is also my cousin, through some
convoluted genealogical maze. It sounds intriguing, and, of course, this
guy's also related to me, supposedly, so I'd like to read it. I'm kind of
afraid he's full of shit, though. I'll let you know by the end of the
week.
12:30am
The Dismemberment Plan, "I love a Magician"
Oh, here we go again!
This is a followup to Josh's prescient previous post: I was going to write
about this phenomenon well before the topic was a glimmer in Josh's eye
(it's just a cliched metaphor; it may not be true). Anyway, one night a
few weeks ago, while avoiding preparing for my finals, I was surfing
through a bunch of reviews (I'll find the link later, when Google is more
cooperative) of Emergency & I. Most of the reviews were very
positive, if not declaring the album the absolute greatest of 1999.
However, many of them mentioned "I love a Magician" in a bewildered,
sometimes even negative, way. Why is this?
Yes, "I love a Magician" is out there. But Jesus Christ, listen to it.
It's fucking beautiful is what it is. Do you not hear Eric's bass-matic
mastery? Everyone says they like the Plan's funky bass, and it doesn't get
any funkier, L's & G's. Do you not hear Joe keeping time on his set,
keepin' things together like Joe Morello? And, lyrically speaking, who
can't relate to the black magic that is a controlling relationship?
But -- and more related to Josh's previous post -- I also like "I love a
Magician" for external reasons. I like that last half of the disc much
better than the first. The album as a whole isn't very long (45 minutes),
but I like the last half so much that I think it could almost be an album
in its own right, and this mini-album would obviously start with "I love a
Magician". So, when the near-moribund "Jitters", which seems to take
itself too seriously, a trait not found on many Plan songs, comes to an
end, and Travis screams out "Oh, here we go again!", I get pretty damn
excited, because the song signifies that the Plan are picking it up and
hurtling towards the end of the disc, to the ultra-sublime "Back and
Forth". Mmmmmmmm... anticipalicious... <drool>
12:23am
Ladies and Gentlemen, allow me to introduce myself... My name is Jon
Stewart, and I am the Ebert to Josh's obvious Siskel, the Calvin to his
Hobbes. When you think of Josh, I'm sure you think of French cinema and
German art music; when you think of me, think of Die Hard 2: Die
Harder and the works of Led Zeppelin. Still, like Ebert, I'll try my
best to hide my essentially white trash values and sound like I'm educated
and erudite. Or something.
Anyway, I probably own fewer CDs than anyone else who reads josh blog, so
don't expect me to comment on anything too obscure. What I lack in
breadth, I make up for with (look! 3 consecutive prepositions!) blind
insistence. I fully expect to exhaust my thoughts concerning all things
musical by the end of the week, when Josh will resume his public
pontificating. As if that weren't apology enough, I probably won't be able
to post as frequently as Josh normally does, as I am busy with
holiday-ing. Still, I'll make a good-faith effort.
A brief bio, for those who care: 22, fifth year senior at the University
of Iowa (NOT Iowa State University, for you out-of-staters),
double-majoring in CS and Linguistics, lazy, poor, employed part-time by a
subsidiary of The Man, Inc., 6'2", black hair/blue eyes, muscular build,
devilishly handsome.
To bitch, send email to: stew1@avalon.net
December 25, 2000
11:59 PM
With that, I leave you until January 1, 2001, in the capable (I hope)
hands of my friend Jon.
11:57 PM
Against my better judgment I am going to list the rest of the songs
here - I hope to say a few words about them next year (!) when I return
from my holiday.
"The Flood"
"Ole"
"Casablanca Moon"
"Risingson (Underworld Mix)"
"Unfinished Sympathy (Perfecto Mix)"
"Sly (Underdog Mix)"
"Inertia Creeps (State of Bengal Mix)"
"The Plan"
"The Diamond Sea"
"Welcome to the Terrordome"
"Ysabel's Table Dance"
"The Ice of Boston"
"Dramamine"
"(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction"
"Norwegian Wood"
"Return of the 'G'"
"Skew It on the Bar-B"
"Aquemini"
"Da Art of Storytellin' (Part 1)"
"Da Art of Storytellin' (Part 2)"
"Liberation"
"Wheelz of Steel"
"Elevators (Me and You)"
"Wailin'"
"Decatur Psalm"
"13 Floor/Growin' Old"
"The Night"
"Take Me With You When You Go"
"Shame"
"Be Thankful for What You've Got"
"Black Steel in the Hour of Chaos"
"Trans-Europe Express"
"Girl from Ipanema"
"Highway 61 Revisited"
"Words and Guitar"
"Dig Me Out"
"Turn It On"
"The Drama You've Been Craving"
"The Size of Our Love"
"Memorize Your Lines"
"8pt Agenda"
"Twice the First Time"
"Your Revolution"
"The Thrill is Gone"
"25 Minutes to Go"
"Haitian Fight Song"
So, there you go - another fifty or so of the songs that I liked most,
listened to most, was most changed by, or otherwise found it meaningful
to list, for 2000.
11:55 PM
Arab Strap, "The Drinking Eye"
Scottish indie g-funk?
11:54 PM
The Dismemberment Plan, "Respect Is Due"
I need a woman, so I can break up with her, and then play this a lot.
11:53 PM
Arab Strap, "Cherubs"
I'm not sure what's more surprising, that it got me to buy
an Arab Strap record, or that it got Tom to.
11:51 PM
Arab Strap, "New Birds"
I've never had quite the experience chronicled in this song, but the
way he puts it, I feel that I have.
Modern rock radio needs more love (?) songs like this.
11:51 PM
Charming Hostess, "Dali Tzerni"
Modern rock radio is just crying out for a bassline like this.
11:49 PM
Diamanda Galas, "My World Is Empty Without You"
I still haven't heard the original - Diana Ross I think? - but I still
maintain that by recordings alone, Diamanda's world has to
sound emptier than Diana's.
11:47 PM
Thelonious Monk, "'Round Midnight (In Progress)"
From the Riverside box, 28 minutes or so of Monk practicing "'Round
Midnight," with the tape left running. Listen to one of the architects
of modern jazz fiddle with the pieces - what could be more fascinating?
Works surprisingly well as a drone record.
11:45 PM
Outkast
"Gasoline Dreams"
"Ms. Jackson"
"B.O.B."
THE THRASH
This entry was brought to by the letters "M," "K," and "J".
11:37 PM
Autechre, "Eggshell"
Merely helped confirm my hypothesis that they have always
been from another planet all along.
11:32 PM
Einsturzende Neubauten
"Sabrina"
"Musentango"
"Dingsaller"
I read somewhere the bass described on this album as "subterranean,"
and that does nicely. "Nocturnal" should be in there too, though -
which is too bad, because this music seems most fit for being played
loudly at 3 AM, which is not such a good time for my neighbors.
11:29 PM
Thelonious Monk, "Japanese Folk Song"
Part of the reason I'm going so slowly through the complete Riverside
recordings is this album, Straight, No Chaser, and in particular
this song. Monk's music is very hard, very angular, and the production
on the album and the music here just emphasize that even more. Compared
to this, a lot of the Riverside box feels a little rounded-off.
11:27 PM
Thelonious Monk, "This is My Story, This is My Song"
My old single review
still says it best, I think.
This Christmas I was reminded of what a great song "Silent Night" is,
too.
11:25 PM
Lamb, "Cotton Wool"
Amazing - despite the stuttering drums, more like gunshots to the
skull than parts of a song - it still feels like a love song.
And, am I ever a sucker for upright bass.
11:23 PM
Miles Davis
"Filles De Kilimanjaro," "Mademoiselle Mabry," from Filles De Kilimanjaro
"He Loved Him Madly," from Get Up With It
Main Entry: protean
Function: adjective
1 : of or resembling Proteus in having a varied nature or ability to
assume different forms
2 : displaying great diversity or variety : VERSATILE
The tie to Proteus (a sea-god from Greek myth) is probably one reason
this word seems reserved for especially towering figures: and Miles,
he was fucking towering. Some time ago I told myself, "self, you've
got to stop buying so much Miles Davis, or you'll never find out about
any other jazz." But it's so hard to stop - he's got an enormous
catalogue, and most of it is at the very least good, and lots of it
is just plain excellent. Records like the above are overshadowed by
In a Silent Way or Nefertiti or Bitches Brew,
but coming from a lesser musician, they would have been career-defining.
Miles just dropped them along the way to other things (though, notably,
Get Up With It was dropped on the way to Miles' "retirement"
and eighties decline). This is why I continue to buy Miles Davis
records, against my desires to expand my knowledge: he's got more
for me to learn than a million other records. There are things here,
in just these three songs, that probably still haven't been adequately
explored by Miles' successors, in jazz or not.
11:09 PM
Sleater-Kinney
"Ironclad"
"Youth Decay"
"The Professional"
"Was It a Lie?"
"Milkshake 'n' Honey"
I wish I had been able to write about this album, All Hands on
the Bad One, right around the time of my epiphany, but I
just couldn't get anything down on paper that I was happy with.
Now a lot of that's lost.
There's something very artfully casual about their guitar playing
here; many songs and riffs sound as if they're begun in-progress -
as if you're hearing something that's already been playing for a bit.
Much has been made of the more reserved Sleater-Kinney on display here.
Well, some of us needed it. I had Call the Doctor, on the
basis of some hype that I bought into, and was a little disappointed
because to me it seemed their great innovation was little more than
"sing screechy and make everything else sound that way too." Oh,
how wrong I was. The reservedness here, compared to Call the
Doctor or Dig Me Out, only served to show me what exactly
they were doing before. The vocals in particular seem more expressive
to me now - and thus the older ones seem purposeful, not simply
uncontrolled emotional leakage. To the contrary: highly
controlled emotionas. Cutting. Piercing.
But it's the songs that pulled me in. I still think, even after being
pulled in by the band's back catalogue, that these are their best,
in the conventional sense, songs. And because most of their catalogue's
songs still follow conventional forms, I don't see why one shouldn't
take that as a sign of their continual development as a band, despite
the qualms some people have with them becoming "more commercial"
(whatever the hell that means - wouldn't you rather hear this on
the radio than matchbox twenty?)
I'm still not sure how to take the gender-switch on "Milkshake
'n' Honey," and I don't think I ever will be.
In part, just the fact that this music hit me was enough to endear
it to me - it had been a while since I had felt so powerfully drawn
to an album. And this was after circling around it for weeks
at KURE, playing a track here or there.
10:55 PM
Mr. Bungle, "Pink Cigarette"
So I was in the throes of the spring semester at this point, by
now probably totally in cruise-control mode - hoping that my brain
would get me through despite oversleeping, not sleeping, not reading,
reading when too sleepy, etc. I must've been both very tired and
very concerned about getting things done that day that I bought
California, because, tucked into a chair somewhere on the
second floor of the library, I kept alternating between drifting off,
and waking up and flipping through some boring book, berating myself.
And wishing the air conditioning was more powerful, because it
was hot that day.
Mr. Bungle didn't make thing any better. What the hell is this?
Are they serious, or not? About what, exactly? The most beautiful
thing about this track is that you can't even play it to demonstrate
to your friends how weird Mr. Bungle is, because it doesn't sound
weird enough, until you've heard the "weirder" tracks on the rest
of the album. Then - oh, then - at least for me, it sticks out
like a beacon. It is, you see, a ballad - delicately, expansively
crooned by Mike Patton.
Not good music for the sleep-deprived. Or maybe, perfect music for
them. Later that day I was walking around playing "Ars Moriendi"
on repeat. And trying not to grin sinisterly at people I passed.
10:48 PM
The Dismemberment Plan:
"You Are Invited"
"Gyroscope"
"The City"
"Girl O'Clock"
"8 1/2 Minutes"
"Back and Forth"
It took me the whole year to be sure, but now I know that Emergency
& I is one of my absolute favorite albums, above everything else
save two by Miles and one by Low (and I don't even know how to compare
them). The rest of the album is great, but it was these songs - not
coincidentally tracks 7 through 12, in order, the whole last half
of the album - that hammered it home for me.
What do I write about songs like these? Songs that I've listened to so
much, in so many different times, places, moods, situations? Maybe
that is, in part, why the album did make it so high onto my list (which
is really just another way of saying, so deep into my head, so much
a part of me) - hardly a day or two went by that I didn't play it,
at least once.
I can tell you this: that if you start playing "You Are Invited"
just as you walk out the northwest door of Carver Hall on the ISU
campus, and then walk northwest whichever way it was I walked,
through the forest in Emma McCarthy Lee Park, and then up Michigan
Avenue, if you slow up just right as you're making your way up
Michigan (because you see you've sped up on the way through the
woods, hearing the other songs), "Back and Forth" will finish
just as you reach the front door of 1234 Michigan Avenue, where
I lived for 3 years.
My walk home barely takes me through "Gyroscope" now, so sometimes
I get the urge to just keep walking.
10:35 PM
Sonic Youth, "Sunday"
Maybe it's slightly ironic that the song that helped re-open Sonic
Youth to me is the "commercial" "single" from A Thousand Leaves,
but hey, whatever works. From here I warmed to the rest of the album,
great in its own right, and then to much other Sonic Youth that I'd
never liked, never bought, or had never realized was so good.
I detect a kinship here between the center section and the solo in
Yo La Tengo's cover of "Little Honda".
10:26 PM
Masada, "Bith-Aneth"
When I was a teenager I made it a point to learn the names of all
the songs on my CDs, but I sort of gave that up somewhere along
the way. Maybe it just got too hard - I was spending too much time
listening to the CDs, trying to keep up.
John Zorn's Jewish roots jazz project makes things even harder on
me, because all of Masada's songs are named in Hebrew, and thus not
really distinguishable to me. I had to look the name of this one
up, and it's one of my favorites of Zorn's - a slow, smoldering
vamp in a Middle Eastern mode typical of Masada. The music makes
a case for Zorn as an improviser, performer, and composer. Hey,
Wynton Marsalis: what the hell is wrong with you?
When I think of the song, I don't think of its name, of course,
because I can't remember it. I think: "that second song," it being
the second song on the first disc of Live in Jerusalem.
I also think of it as simply "<the bass line>" in my head,
perhaps sort of subvocalized, however it is exactly that I "hear"
music mentally (I'm still not sure how that works).
The first time I heard this was some spring afternoon; I had gone to
the library to wait for Lisa, who showed up late and then took me
out on the bus to where her car was parked. So, now I always think
of Lisa when I hear this.
10:19 PM
Yo La Tengo, "You Can Have It All"
OK, so obviously I liked this record a lot. There's a reason it
was at the head of my albums list. I could pick more songs off of it,
if I wanted.
I could cite the hypnotic indie-fied disco shuffle, or Georgia Hubley's
vocals, or the men's (I think James helps Ira out here) ba-ba-ba-ba-ba
backing vocals, or plenty of other things as reasons for liking the
song over the others on the record. None of those quite do it, though,
because they're reasons I like most of the songs on the record.
Buy this record and give it a few months, dammit. It's good.
10:10 PM
Yo La Tengo, "Cherry Chapstick"
For a long time I was a bit let down by this song, the only guitar-freakout
on And then nothing turned itself inside-out. Let down, mostly
because for all the restraint shown elsewhere, I wanted a really big
release.
I've since grown to like the song a lot. Most of the album is hazy,
the way you would expect something that sounds so rooted in long-ago
memories to be. The guitar freakout sounds accordingly hazy - warm,
somewhat muted. More glowing that the situation depicted in the song
might have been, experienced firsthand.
10:09 PM
Yo La Tengo, "Tears Are In Your Eyes"
I make it a point to not play this on my headphones. I've only ever
cried a couple of times listening to music, but I suspect this one
could do it. No reason to go bawling in public.
10:07 PM
OK, take a deep breath. I'm going to start throwing out brief thoughts
on my list of songs for the year. I know I could collect these all
on one page, but I feel I'll get a perverse satisfaction out of blogging
them as I go.
Plus I have to mark my territory well before Jon steps in at midnight.
8:58 PM
I always love a good Christmas
tale.
5:13 PM
A not altogether serious article
about synaesthesia and music which Fred should enjoy anyway.
12:08 AM
Or maybe I'll listen to the whole thing.
December 24, 2000
11:41 PM
I still have time to walk home from my office so I can make a symbolic
gesture (I do make a few every now and then, you know) and listen to
Low's Christmas album. Probably just "Blue Christmas" though.
2:39 PM
Three thoughts
Last night coming home I heard "Silent Night" coming from a neighbor's
apartment. It was enormous, with full orchestra, backing choir, etc.
I hated it. Low is the officially approved josh blog performer of
"Silent Night".
Second-period King Crimson is also one of the heaviest bands ever.
In that they share something with Soundgarden. It comes, I think,
from their rhythm section, especially Bill Bruford's "Chinese" drumming -
undercuts forward motion just enough to make the beat seem slow.
I heard Ozzy's "No More Tears" at the restaurant last night, and let
me tell you, Ozzy was never all that heavy. King Crimson: heavy.
I am noticing that my listening choices are carefully skirting around
the more depressing music I own. I hate to call it that, because it's
much more than that - I don't want to be limiting - but at the moment,
it's depressing. I would love it if I have some more Motown right now.
3:01 AM
Someone on r.m.p. said
I also listen with friends who are record collectors and after similar
stuff. We usually have a large listening session meeting every Sunday
afternoon where everybody brings his new acquisitions and we stay till late
night commenting and chatting on music.
I used to do that with Damon. Just whenever new music arose, though.
2:56 AM
On taste - something I also often think about is, what could it be about
some peoples' tastes that would make them not like this music?
2:49 AM
Also, Robert Fripp's "one note" (he really plays lots of notes, he
just sits on on figure and modulates it upward repeatedly) guitar
solo on "Starless" reminds me:
Once I was sitting with Damon, listening to I think some kind of jazz
CD, and the soloist had gotten onto one of those bits where he played
the same note, repeatedly, for a long time. Damon articulated the
following, which I always think about now whenever I hear a similar
solo:
It's great when they do that, because you don't know where they're
going to go.
A little more on what he meant, maybe: even in rock guitar solos,
where the idea of "development" is replaced more by some kind of
standard of progressive freaking-out-edness, or something, the
way most solos go implies a kind of direction, most times - it makes
sense that they do certain things, because of what they've previously
played. When a player hangs on one note long enough, the recent
memory of that development is kind of erased - a brand new context
is established, which makes for bigger surprises when change does
occur.
Fripp's "one note" solo takes advantage of this even further, because
there's a double effect: that of the tension and surprise from the
repeated notes, and a longer-term tension made apparent once you realize
that he's going to continue ascending the scale with his repeated
single-note cells. So on the short-term, you get the one-note effect,
and you also get it on the long-term.
2:25 AM
So I'm listening again to the new remastered edition of King Crimson's
Red album, and have a few thoughts.
1. I am very stricken, at the moment, by how much my liking this music
seems to be in large part a simple matter of familiarity and exposure.
By that I mean: the music is at the very least well-done according to
some set of criteria. The more important part seems to be that
I find it acceptable. This is why it's called "taste" - there are
affinities, similarities, with food. Ten years ago (?) I might have
told you that my favorite food was steak. This is not so today (in
fact, I'm not sure I have a favorite food). Steak hasn't gotten any
worse, really, I think - it's just that I no longer have the same
desire to consume it. Similarly, I didn't used to enjoy tomato
juice, but I've grown to like it. Some familiarity has been established,
built up.
When I first started listening to King Crimson, I was more receptive -
my tastes were in such a state that it was easy for me to like
King Crimson. Musically, I'm somewhat still receptive, I think, but
if I were to pick up something similar, the lyrics would be a much
bigger deterrent to me (King Crimson's lyrics not being terrible,
but not the greatest in the world either - their most unfortunate
aspect, though they are head and shoulders above most progressive
rock). There's something fortuitous about it - I was lucky. Because
it's good music in that first sense - well-done according to some
set of criteria. (This is an idea I come back to a lot, that music
can be somehow divided into "good by some rules," and "good because
I like those rules".)
2. I love the packaging for this album, and also the remastered
Larks' Tongues in Aspic. Slightly oversized cardboard CD
folders, replicas of gatefold LP covers, with excellent printing.
There's something more substantial-feeling about them because of
the packaging. I just want to sit and hold them in my hands.
3. On a somewhat related note: I don't know if I've mentioned it
before, but I am still highly amused at one of the clippings in
the Larks' Tongues notes. The new liner notes to both
reissues include lots of newspaper clippings about King Crimson
from the times of release. Larks' Tongues includes - get this -
a columnist from Cosmo - yes that Cosmo - giving a favorable
review to a new King Crimson album. And she's hot, to boot. I'm
not sure what parallel this could have today. It could be a current-day
Cosmo columnist reviewing The ConstruKction of Light, but
a) King Crimson are no longer contemporary, exactly, and b)
oh how far they have slipped. A Mogwai review, then, perhaps?
December 22, 2000
6:21 PM
JAMES BROWN IS A FUNK MACHINE
2:12 PM
Two Fugazi songs that I am just today noticing the lyrics of.
do you like me - your eyes like crashing jets fixed in stained
glass but not religious you should pay rent in my mind like the french
say bon soir regret a demain do you like me i guess white witness
moves to petition the state of virginia for 27 prisons while in bethesda
an office flaming youth group singing firemen calling in lockheed
lockheed martin marietta do you like me i guess end of the lesson
time for one question end of the lesson time for one more question
do you like me
bed for the scraping - i'm sick with this i'm sick with this
situations avoided or just missed? my own sweet time says it's
tentwentyfour hardlyrecognize simple things anymore i don't want to
be defeated this is the point this is the manifest bed for the
scraping dirty little secret reason for the gathering consequence
what else is there to do but go outside look around look around
I may not be keeping track well enough to use josh blog for this
in the future - that's a matter to be determined then - but I
think it will be helpful in letting me see what I thought of music
before I liked it. Red Medicine, for example, the album
that these songs came from, is one of my favorite albums ever.
I can remember a time, though, when I thought it was abrasive
as hell, and probably just plain shitty and worthless. Also
perhaps reedy and thin-sounding. But these are all just suppositions,
because I don't remember very well what I thought. I do remember
that I owned In on the Kill Taker before Red Medicine,
and that I found it used (because it still has the sticker on it),
and that I bought it on the recommendation of someone from a
bulletin board on the computer, because I was dissatisfied with
how limited my musical selections were - even walking into a larger
store, I had no idea what to buy beyond, mostly, what I heard on
the radio. As for Red Medicine, I don't remember if I owned
it when I came to college or if I bought it because Rob told me to.
During my freshman year at college I met Rob Ruminski, who is shall
we say a "character". Passionate, intelligent, fervent, frustrated,
uncouth, experienced - but devoted to so many things that I wasn't,
like politics and labor and injustice. And also he thought most of
my music was crap (some of it he was right about, but some of it
he wasn't). So we chafed at one another, a little bit, but in good
ways.
Anyway, Red Medicine was, he claimed, perhaps one of the
GREATEST ALBUMS EVER, so for some reason or another (probably
just stubborness) I took it upon myself to figure out why. Much
to my roommate Damon's annoyance, because, really, it is a pretty
abrasive album when you're not used to it. Especially the "singing";
the feedback that closes "by you"; hell, most of it.
I moved out of the dorms the next year and didn't see Rob much, and
he dropped out anyway. I've encountered him again a couple of times,
and we clashed some more. Maybe we will again.
The thing is, I can't remember when I started liking that album.
Or how. What I thought. Anything. I know it was soon - maybe I
can cap it by the summer after that, or the next one. I don't know.
You see, josh blog is also helping me build a framework for my
memories. Which is another good reason to put those song lyrics
up there.
2:46 AM
This week's TWAS
is brilliant, absolutely brilliant. Up to the part where the music
review starts, about 7/9 of the way through. It's funny, that used
to be my favorite review site, but now I read it every week for
the preambles, and skim the rest.
Which means, of course, that the part I mean for you to read isn't
actually about music at all. It's about Evil. And what kind of
new car Kant would buy.
December 21, 2000
7:21 PM
And, though I don't know how I can indicate to you how remarkable
this may seem without your hearing this music for yourself, it
makes me calm and peaceful and sleepy. This jagged mass of honking
and battering and dissonance. This is not unlike my reaction to
Coltrane's other late-period work, and remember that I don't regard
the fact that music can make me sleepy as a flaw - rather, it's
a virtue.
If you don't understand the music within at all, Alice Coltrane's
comment in the liner notes could seem almost like she's enjoying
a cruel inside joke to which the reader (listener) is not privy:
The music of this album is reminiscent of so much of the spiritual
joy and peace we felt during our most memorable stay in Japan.
6:48 PM
I can't really say that there's much "swing" in the way Rashied Ali
plays most of the time, but it's very interesting how he suddenly
plays much more conventionally beneath Alice Coltrane's long solo,
about 40 minutes into "My Favorite Things". It could be mistaken
for swing, even. He's still very choppy, though. I've always thought
Elvin Jones' playing with Coltrane often had a choppy feel to it,
which I suppose makes sense because of all the polyrhythms he played.
Ali is far moreso, though.
Point of comparison: the drums in "Airbag" from OK Computer.
Alice Coltrane's solos are always ringing, flowery, full of heavily
pounded left hand chords, and often right as well, as she blends
together resonant clusters of chords with insistent, endless
glissandi. Very, very different from McCoy Tyner.
When John re-enters late in the song on soprano, the sound is so pinched
that it sounds like an oboe.
6:26 PM
The sticker on the front of the Arab Strap album I also just received,
The Week Never Starts Round Here, says
First domestic release of the ARAB STRAP debut album. Containing
at least one bonus track.
At least one?
5:39 PM
Among other things, John Coltrane Live in Japan has arrived in
my mailbox, a Christmas gift from my parents.
I don't know how, but I expected it to sound as big as the sky.
It doesn't, but it is still very great. The 57-minute version of
"My Favorite Things" (the sole track on disc 4) is: soothing, stable,
solid, soaring, cacophonous, jittery, roiling, churning, majestic,
inscrutable, intense.
Also, some questions come to mind:
- Why was Coltrane so generous in alotting bass solo time to Jimmy
Garrison? His solos are very good, but it still is a bit unorthodox,
I think. Though it's not as if that were the only unorthodox thing
about this highly idiosyncratic group.
- What the hell is Rashied Ali doing? And why do I still like it?
- Why have the Japanese treated jazz so well?
3:53 PM
THIS IS A BIRTHDAY PONY
6:24 AM
It's 6:24 in the am (see time above ha) and I just did a logic
puzzle. Be afraid, be very afraid.
2:00 AM
Last spring when taking a philosophy of mathematics seminar I had
something of a revelation when I realized that, because the people
we were reading were not dead (this being something of a rarity
in lots of philosophy), I could mail them and ask them direct
questions about points I was confused on. Philosophers sort of
having a problem with being one hundred percent understandable all
the time, you know.
So I never did get around to that, finishing my big paper and the
course without recoursing to direct badgering of busy philosophers.
But it occurred to me the other day that when I get some things
done and find time to finish Generation Ecstasy, I can
bother Simon
Reynolds directly. How cool is the internet?
December 20, 2000
9:06 PM
A sentence from the biographical entry for Roger McGough
in my copy of the Norton
Anthology of Modern Poetry copyrighted 1973.
In the early Sixties the rock group called the Beatles made their
first reputation in Liverpool.
Oh, academics.
In context, this sentence seems intended as purely informationally
as e.g.
Liverpool is a large industrial city in the north of England, a
rather grim product of the Industrial Revolution.
which is the first in the entry.
I'm surprised I didn't see things near the beginning of the book
like
Near the end of the eighteenth century a man named George Washington
became the president of a country called the United States of America.
8:44 PM
So the last cut on that Coltrane album is "The Drum Thing," which
though it has a head and tail with Trane blowing and some bass
transitions for those, is mostly Elvin soloing. I would say that this
is a prime example of how drum solos can be good rather than bad,
but I don't really want to hunt through my CDs to find a bad (is
that redundant?) rock drum solo, which is the likely place to look.
On a live album no doubt. Oh, that's not fair, because I own some live
Rush, and Neil Peart's solos aren't terrible. He knows his limits,
at least. But it gets much worse elsewhere, very quickly.
Anyway: the Elvin solo. Churns and rolls. I think at a moment or two
I'm even tempted to attribute psychedelic qualities to it. Yes, to
a drum solo. He's really good. Really.
8:38 PM
I forgot below to say why the straight jazz.
It's precisely because of the emotional qualities jazz has, which
qualities I've pointed out before. When I listen I have emotional
experiences, but they're abstract, not the same kinds of emotions
as I get listening to lovelorn indie rock or superfunk or whatever -
and more importantly, they're not negative, for the most part.
They unnerve me less when I'm looking for comfort. Tom remarked to
me tonight that he usually pulls out the trusted favorites when
he's feeling down. But a lot of my trusted favorites are not to
be trusted when I'm down, even as much as I love them.
7:37 PM
Miles Davis' "Rated X" - the version from Get Up With It - is
genius. It's similar to the version from On the Corner, but
the band is busier and it battles Miles on extremely dischordant organ.
The band is repeatedly muted with studio trickery, so that they drop
in and out at a moment's notice, and the track is all the more
jarring. The rhythm, when it kicks in at the beginning, is monstrous.
This wipes the floor with all kinds of contemporary music.
Now, I know there's no "Rated X" on On the Corner, because
I just checked. Ha. It so sounds like a mutant track from
On the Corner, though. So I will leave things like this.
I'll listen to that album again though - maybe it sounds like
"Mr. Freedom X", and was just given a new name.
This too is amazing to hear, more amazing, at loud volumes.
In fact it turned my room into a DENSE, SEETHING DEN OF FUNK this
afternoon. I took it with me on a walk, which turned out to be
a mistake as I was upset and the tenor of the music exacerbated
things. By the time I neared home I was practically running.
So for the rest of the night I've been listening to straight
jazz. Well, Impulse-era Coltrane and also "Ole", but still. It
struck me that Elvin Jones sounded incredibly boring for Elvin
Jones, on Crescent. So I looked at the credits and said,
aha, it's because it was not Elvin Jones. But, I must have been
tripping. It is Elvin Jones, it says so right here. It's been
that kind of night.
I can whistle along with lots of the solos on this album, so
I guess I'm more familiar with it than I remembered.
The last memory I have sitting around in the head about it is
from a year, maybe two, ago - sitting in the extended entryway
to the library, listening to "Wise One" on repeat, writing proofs
and watching the pretty girls walk by.
It's a nice memory.
2:25 PM
So yesterday the manager of my local music store called me up and
offered me a job (but retracted it when he found out I would be
gone at the end of the summer) - he said he liked to hire people
from the pool of regulars. There are obviously two advantages to
doing this.
First, he knows that they know a lot about music, in some respect.
Assuming they aren't coming in all the time and buying music that
they don't listen to. Like they go shoot skeet or something.
Second, he knows the employees will turn around and spend lots of
their pay in the store. Ha.
It was nice to be asked, though.
4:28 AM
Now listening to: Satie, "Three Flabby Preludes (for a Dog)". Ha.
December 19, 2000
11:33 PM
Listening to Autechre's Amber, borrowed from a friend because
I still don't have it. Definitely bridges the gap between their
first and last albums. However, listening to it I wasn't completely
sure if it was before Tri Repetae, or after. (Before - Chiastic
Slide was after.) It has similarities to Incunabula, for
sure, but also to LP5.
I don't really know what to say about "Teartear," but it's very good.
I would much rather "experimental" rap followed this up, than, say,
rapping over DJ Spooky tracks.
Or e.g. Kool Keith - he could sound more like he really was from
outer space, less like he's from a bad porn flick.
A nice review
by Ned again, too, in his endless quest to de-suck the AMG.
9:51 PM
One thing that must be kept in mind at all times when listening to
Miles Davis' fusion era music: live, he played this stuff loud.
So what about at home? Shouldn't we too?
The answer is: I hope the neighbors like "Calypso Frelimo".
9:48 PM
It just occurred to me that with my recent acquisition of Q and Not U's
No Kill No Beep Beep, I now have a CD to file under "Q". Hooray
me. Hooray collectorism. Hooray not owning a Queen CD.
8:36 PM
Now, I like rock music. Music with guitars and such. Insistent
rock backbeats. Various kinds of yelling, screaming. Higher-than-normal
frequency of the words
However. If there's one thing I hate, and which makes me not want
to hear a band, it's reading them described with "rockers" used
as an adjective.
It always seems to come up when used by (a) journalists who wouldn't
know rock if it bit them on the ass, and (b) people describing
Metallica or Tommy Lee.
3:54 AM
Regarding year-end lists, "Chit Duree" wrote me with another very
salient point that I really should've mentioned myself already:
year-end lists generally happen at the end of the year, which means
they're almost decided by the end of November anyway. But music
that was good to you in June might not be in December, and music
you hear in December might sound great, or not, and then sound
differently six months down the road. Making a list at the year's
end puts a too-arbitrary cap on one's appreciation. Couple this
with the other problems I mentioned, and, well...
I should mention, then, the number of things that I put on my own
little lists below, which I've only heard recently. The Mekons
and Arab Strap in particular. Remember that my lists just pick
out the things that hit me hardest, impressed me most. There's
some equivocation there. Releases from earlier in the year have
had more time to wear off. If I had heard Built to Spill's live
album for the first time last week, I might've been enamored enough
with it to mention it.
List as a snapshot in time; no claims to normativity.
3:07 AM
Splendid interview
with John Darnielle of the Mountain Goats.
I find it somewhat odd and cool that Darnielle currently lives in Ames.
In fact, the new Mountain Goats CD The Coroner's Gambit contains
a brief missive from Darnielle in the notes, where he talks about how
he lives a couple blocks north of Emma McCarthy Lee Park, which is
pretty much where I used to live for the past three years.
I think perhaps I'm a tiny bit awed by this just because CDs still have
some kind of fetishistic power for me. Obviously. CDs are special, things
out there - so when one that even garners national attention (I
first found out that Darnielle lived in Ames thanks to Ned mentioning
I think Darnielle's fanzine for a completely unrelated reason), even
on a small small scale, finds its way to me, with a connection that
seems personally relevant to me, there's something... unbelievable
about it.
(Same goes for CDs that people I know have appeared on. Moreso even.)
December 18, 2000
10:55 PM
Richard
Crawford is cool: an academic who writes about American music and has
his head on straight enough to understand the role popular and folk musics
(and performance and records and a number of oter things) have had in
it.
5:35 PM
Miles Davis, Get Up With It - very nice.
3:30 AM
And another thing about year-end lists...
In addition to my not being happy with their focus on the past year
specifically, to the detriment of the remainder (as if it were small)
of one's listening activities, I don't like how they also
seem to be regarded as things which somehow end the year: by December
31, if an album hasn't made it onto one's year-end list, it's
to large extent forgotten about. There are a few stragglers the
year later, but mostly, lists often serve as some kind of codification
of the "good" releases of the year.
Listening is not a contest.
If I like an album, what would be a better thing for me to do, if
I want to share how much I like the album? Put a "1." next to its
name, or try to write (at whatever length necessary) about why I
like it so much?
Of course, these can go hand in hand. But I suspect that the presence
of a list engenders feelings of pronouncement, oracularity, in many
writers. As if little needed to be said about an album with a "1."
next to its name, as if it were self-evident why one would want to
hear the album.
I like some lists. They have their purposes. Ned and
Tom and
Fred
and Maura have all written
lists that interest me, fascinate me, inspire me.
What follows may be a little presumptuous, I'm not sure.
In terms of writing, a list is a formal constraint. An organizing
principle. Tom and Ned's lists in particular feel to me as if they
don't even need the constraint. For Tom, the list feels as if it
was the germ of the resulting collection of writing - it provided
the guide for him as he wrote, but the end product, because he took
the time to focus in writing on everything in the list, became
much broader: encompassing thoughts on the course of pop history
in the 90s, the nature of sound and music and the listening experience,
Tom's own personal experience. As for Ned, personal experience feels
even more key. There are 136 albums, because that's what seemed right to
Ned. The constraint here was a limiting one: how else to cram your
life, with music, over 10 years, into something to share with others?
Answer: try to figure out which things feel important enough, and
stop when you've got enough that that feels right too.
I like Fred's list because of its focus. Also lack of it. Maura's too.
I care more about their lists because I like them as people. I
interact with them. I'm interested in what they have to say about
music, as I am with Tom and Ned, because I can connect what they
say to the whole complex of things I know about them and their
tastes.
I don't need personal connections to make music writing interesting
to me. But it certainly fleshes out the experience of reading lists,
which are an impoverished mode of communication when delivered
with no sort of commentary or reflection. I'd be interested in
Tom's and Ned's lists even if I didn't like Tom and Ned, simply
because there are enough indications throughout the lists'
contents that individuals' tastes and lives went into them.
Compare this to the much-discussed (well not really) Pitchfork
year-end-list, which was obtained by consensus - voting.
I'm not all that interested in what groups have to say about
what music was good, as opposed to people. That tells me that
lots of people liked something; it often misses on the why.
(A lengthy analogy between grocery lists and year-end lists has
been snipped here, but I'll talk about it with you if you're
really interested.)
3:23 PM
I actually found this via Greil Marcus' real life top 10. But I
can't be bothered to find the link to that again.
From
Extracts from the Teenage Diary of Colin B. Morton, which runs
in Clicks And Klangs,
which is good and which you should look at.
Interestingly enough, William Hague, leader of the UK Tory Party,
has recently come out in defence of a man who shot dead a youth who
was trespassing on his private property. Even more recently the UK
Tory Party has used, without permission, the music of Massive
Attack to help promote the idea that we shouldn't have to pay tax
or care about the sick. Hagues own logic dictates, therefore, that
Massive Attack's Daddy G and 3D should have the right to shoot all
members of the Tory Party dead for trespassing on their
intellectual property. Either Intellectual Property doesnt exist,
or they have that right. Hague cant have it both ways (well he can,
but thats another story entirely).
12:51 AM
John Szwed, author of a book on Sun Ra, from an interview at Perfect
Sound Forever:
The punks got on this pretty quickly- that he was a prototype of
what they were doing. But Sun Ra began to lag a bit though. When he
got into disco, the disco thing was already well under way. When he
recorded Languidity, SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER was also out. He was
really lagging. I really love that record though. It's sort of rare
because people threw it away. It's a kind of disco where you say 'I
know what this is' but it's kind of gnawing at you like warrior
ants. He had the band listen to Donna Summer. One of the band
members said 'Sonny, this is some corny shit.' He said 'this corny
shit is somebody's dreams and hopes and aspirations. Don't be so
hip.' He would be quick to move to these things. 'UFO' has drum
machines and the band softly chanting 'UFO, take me where you want
to go' over and over. It's disco but it's so perverted that you'd
feel foolish dancing to it. He was ahead of things up to that point
and then he went into other modes, one of which was to go
backwards.
December 12, 2000
8:45 PM
No wait it IS
8:45 PM
Oh god if I didn't know better I'd say this was an IDM version of 'Bolero'
6:38 PM
GETchoo, ah ha
GETchoo, ah ha
GETchoo, ah ha
GETCHOO GETCHOO GETCHOo
ah ha (in a falsetto)
this is beginning to hurt (repeat to end)
5:52 PM
Some days I get really good reader mail.
From: "Tom Ewing" <ebros@netcomuk.co.uk>
To: <kortbein@iastate.edu>
Cc: <scarth@intonet.co.uk>
Subject: JOSH! ARE YOU DRINKING?
Date: Tue, 12 Dec 2000 20:53:57 -0000
Greg and I are worried.
Hahahahahahahahaha. Ha!
2:16 PM
yeah I think I'll write a haiku
yeah you know as well as I do
you got ta have a high eye kewwwww
2:05 PM
Christmas music, of a sort: in the middle of "Dawn" Slapp Happy break
into a chorus of "Come, All Ye Faithful". Twice, actually - it seems
to be their own chorus. Not sure yet but the rest of the song seems
to not exactly have much to do with the faithful coming, etc. as
I remember from church and Christmas carols.
12:45 PM
Soul Coughing, "Mr. Bitterness"
What's this? I seem to be dancing. Must put a stop to that immediately. ;)
"Janine"
I'm throwing this one in here too because, well, it starts with a J,
which is rare, and I'd like to get rid of that list of letters over
there eventually. But this is not mere J-tokenism! ;) Because it's
good too. And I notice Tom
has it in his current top ten.
"if you were the Baltic sea and I were a cup, uh-huh"
In Rachel Murdy, who performs the song on the answering machine,
they seem to have found someone even more off-key than M. Doughty. Ha.
It even manages to work Al Roker in without losing its easygoing
romantic charm. Ha ha.
12:40 PM
mmmmmm
aaah
ooh
11:40 AM
you
get
the
AN-
kles
n
I'll
get
th'
WRISTS
10:03 AM
After that I suppose I should note that
Maura, too has a list which you can read.
9:42 AM
Ouch!
I idly note that there are some people who just really like Sleater-Kinney.
;)
9:41 AM
I am also thinking about a list of songs, but that is harder because
I don't have a big list of information to throw around.
9:30 AM
So, for the next list, I should acknowledge that I am making some
kind of cutoff - things that I purchased this past year. This
is mostly because it's easier for me to keep track of that. And I
am lazy. I could look through the josh blog archives to glean
a bit more information about releases of days gone by that I found
myself particularly enamored with this year, but. Lazy.
Here is a list of I think every disc I've
bought (a couple I've been given) in the past year. Because it just
wouldn't be josh blog unless we showed you all the dirty parts that
go into this list I'm making.
The preliminary list below I obtained simply by going down the above
list, and saying "yes" or "no" to myself. When I said "no," that didn't
mean I didn't like the release I was considering. Just that it didn't
meet some unspecific internal criteria for being on this list.
This one just goes in the order I entered them into my computer,
oldest to newest, with a couple out of order because I forgot to
put them in.
Yo La Tengo - And then nothing turned itself inside out
Masada Live in Jerusalem
Sonic Youth - A Thousand Leaves
John Zorn - The Circle Maker
The Dismemberment Plan - Emergency & I
Mr. Bungle - California
Sleater-Kinney - All Hands on the Bad One
Talk Talk - Laughing Stock
Stuart Dempster - Underground Overlays from the Cistern Chapel
Miles Davis - Filles de Kilimanjaro
Thelonious Monk - Straight, No Chaser
Einsturzende Neubauten - Silence is Sexy
Herbie Hancock - Mwandishi: The Complete Warner Brothers Recordings
John Coltrane - Stellar Regions
Massive Attack - Singles 90/98
Autechre - Incunabula
The Sea and Cake - Oui
Dave Holland - Emerald Tears
Stan Getz with Joao Gilberto - Getz/Gilberto
Shellac - At Action Park
Sleater-Kinney - Dig Me Out
Sleater-Kinney - The Hot Rock
Outkast - ATLiens
Mekons - Journey to the End of the Night
Arab Strap - Philophobia
Arab Strap - Elephant Shoe
So now the question is, do I want to do anything else with this
list? What purpose would it serve for me to rank them, if I am
even able to do such a thing?
Yes, I am aware that there are two Arab Strap albums there, two
John Zorn projects, a boxed set, and three Sleater-Kinney albums.
That's just the way things happened this year.
9:16 AM
And in case it isn't obvious, read that from top to bottom.
9:07 AM
Goddammit, everyone is getting all listy for sure now. So I suppose
I should get to it.
This list doesn't mean as much to me as the one I'm going to put here
later. This contains only things released this year. However, when I'm
listening to albums I don't listen with a 2000-mind and a 1973-mind
and a 1988-mind etc., so my relationships with my records are not
so simple that I can in good conscience rank say the new Godspeed over
a number of other records that I loved this year.
The order here is very rough. I don't like ordering things.
Sleater-Kinney - All Hands on the Bad One
Yo La Tengo - And then nothing turned itself inside out
Arab Strap - Elephant Shoe
Mekons - Journey to the End of the Night
Einsturzende Neubauten - Silence is Sexy
The Sea & Cake - Oui
Godspeed You Black Emperor! - Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven
Shellac - 1000 Hurts
Some notable things are not here. Radiohead. Outkast. I liked them, just
not like that.
12:53 AM
Open Letter To Nick Cave
Dear Mr. Cave,
You are a genius. Please record another album.
That is all.
Sincerely,
Josh Kortbein
December 11, 2000
9:58 PM
Phil Turnbull was exceedingly kind, and sent me a CDR of Slapp
Happy tunes, and one of three punk/post-punk type bands he was
in in the late 70s / early 80s. I am not done with my first listen
through yet but am already quite pleased with the Slapp Happy.
I would just like to take this moment to point out the names
of some songs from the Art Bears' (a band involving members of
Slapp Happy and Henry Cow) third album:
1. Song of Investment Capital
7. Song of the Martyrs
9. Song of the Monopolists.
10. Song of DIgnity of Labour
Now, tell me those aren't cool names.
1:46 PM
Maybe "wonder" isn't quite the right word, but there's a quality like
it in lots of Sonic Youth's music that makes me think they were
more prescient in choosing their name than one would immediately
think. Sure, now they're prone to all kinds of lame comments from
reviewers about how "they're not so young any MORE, heh heh!" But:
read the noun in the abstract.
1:20 PM
Interview
with LD Beghtol of Flare, Magnetic Fields, etc.
1:01 PM
And of course the lyric, from "Weather Report" -
it's indie on the radio waves
12:52 PM
The American Analog Set, The Golden Band
Some days it seems the band recorded this just for me, personally.
Loud brushes on the drums. Vibraphone. Bass-driven impressionistic
"songs". Warmth.
2:34 AM
Small moment of brilliance:
The way Matt Cameron keeps the cymbal going for two beats during
the chorus to "Drown Me", right near the end where Chris Cornell
sings the title, right before his dramatic pause.
12:50 AM
I guess I can't just let that sit.
1. The main point is that Evans is not unable to swing. Certainly
it's not all he does, or even the best thing he does.
2. The worst thing about Crouch et al is that their criticism is built
on a kernel of truth. The blues and swing (as a quality, not a genre)
are at the core of much of jazz. But fetishizing some notion
of "authentic" jazz which holds those two things as necessary components
of good jazz is the most wrongheaded part of Crouch's thinking. At
best it gives a head-in-the-sand "genre" that's cordoned off from
the rest of jazz; much of the music that these people revere, after
all, is really great. At worst, it excludes so much good
stuff that it's just pitiful. Obviously Mingus's experiments with
orchestration and tone rows, Evans' explorations of impressionistic
harmony, Coltrane's "anti-jazz", Miles' modal and post-bop work, and fusion,
Getz's samba, Jarrett's standards interpretations (in the vein
begun by Evans, certainly), Dave Holland's (and Ornette's and etc. etc.
etc.) group improve - obviously these things are all "jazz" in some
sense. I'm at least sensitive enough to acknowledge that there's
some rough dividing line - European improv people like Derek Bailey
are off doing something else, related to jazz by virtue of improvisation's
presence, for example - but to be as arbitrary as Crouch about where
the line is is simply foolish.
3. "When you're swinging, swing some more." - T. Monk.
Jon, you really, really should reconsider your miniature swing
diatribe below. As a genre, sure, I'm no big swing fan. But as
a quality of music, jazz in particular, well... a lot of excellent
stuff, post-Swing Era, swings. Monk. Mingus. Bird. Diz. Miles. Coltrane.
Even Stan fucking Getz swings playing Latin music (it's the clave
beat, which isn't really a swing beat, but it still has the feel).
A Jew playing music from a foreign country, and he swings. What
better indication that swing is not some intrinsically black thing,
a la Crouch?